How to plot a novel around a real event – without making it read like a text book

The starting point for my most recent novel, An Ocean of Stars, was a tragic railway disaster that happened near Dundee, Scotland, on December 28, 1879.

Article about the 1879 Tay Bridge disaster, published in French newspaper 1880.
This image is from a French newspaper at the time.  The disaster happened at night and I’m not aware that any dogs were involved in the rescue attempts

It was a Sunday and some fulminated that the collapse of the bridge just as a train was crossing was some sort of retribution for travelling on the Sabbath. Seems a bit harsh, given over 70 people drowned and there were no survivors.

My first step in trying to bring this to life, was to travel by train myself to the River Tay where the bridge collapsed. It was a damp, dreary day (dreich, as the Scots might say). Eerily, you can still see the piers of the original bridge sticking up above the waterline.

Photos taken by the author Imogen Martin of the bridge over the Tay River, showing the uprights from the original bridge that collapsed.

My second step was to concentrate on my characters. I try to write gripping stories, so the historical event is there to make the characters come alive, not the other way round. This book is about Phoebe, the sister of Alexander Van Bergen who was a main character in Under a Gilded Sky. In the earlier book, we briefly see her hard at work with her charitable hospital. 

However, Phoebe lives in Boston, Massachusetts, and the disaster took place in Scotland. So, to help the plot, the doctor who arrived in Boston had to be Scottish. That led to lots of other possibilities as I was planning the book: Edinburgh was acknowledged as the leading city for medical training in the world. Clearly, I needed to get my heroine to Scotland somehow. I decided to send Phoebe to a (sadly, fictional) symposium on women’s health.

The third step was to work backwards methodically from the disaster with the timing of the story’s events. Phoebe had to be in Scotland on December 28, 1879. That meant she would need to spend Christmas there. I didn’t want her hanging around in Scotland for weeks though, so the medical symposium had to happen in December. How long would it take for her to travel there? How long was an Atlantic crossing? When would she need to leave the United States? And so on, step by step, backwards through the story until I eventually came to the date of the first ill-fated meeting between Phoebe and Dr. Douglas McLennan. My first draft had this happen in winter, but by the later draft, I worked out that the plot needed them to first clash horns in May 1879.

By the way, there were no survivors from the real-life disaster. You will have to read the book to find out how I got round that plotting conundrum.

Cover of epic historical romance with a 1879 steam liner crossing the Atlantic

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *